UPSI Digital Repository (UDRep)
Start | FAQ | About

QR Code Link :

Type :thesis
Subject :SB Plant culture
Main Author :Mohammad Rusdi Mohd Nasir
Title :A study of Kelantan Malay cultural landscape: recent trends and future prospects
Place of Production :Tanjong Malim
Publisher :Fakulti Teknikal dan Vokasional
Year of Publication :2011
Corporate Name :Universiti Pendidikan Sultan Idris
PDF Guest :Click to view PDF file
PDF Full Text :Login required to access this item.

Abstract : Universiti Pendidikan Sultan Idris
Due to the scale of recent development and rapid urbanisation in Kelantan, Malaysia, there is a general lack of understanding and appreciation of the Kelantan Malay cultural landscape. This PhD research was undertaken in order to identify the characteristics and identity of the Kelantan Malay cultural landscape. Through this improved understanding, it is hoped to better respect the heritage in contemporary planning and landscape design. The investigation highlights the authentic traditional elements that the inherited landscape can offer to contemporary planners, landscape architects, and municipal administrators in order to preserve the integrity and the beauty of the Kelantan Malay landscape. The search for the Kelantan Malay regional identity is quite a complicated endeavour both because of the diverse causes of change, and the difficulties in obtaining references and documentation about the; Kelantan Malay cultural landscape. There is an urgent and imperative task to secure the future of the authentic Kelantan Malay cultural landscape. Basically, Kelantan is being becoming acknowledged as a cradle of Malay cultures since most of the traditional Malay cultures can be found there. Traditional arts and culture are crucial to regional identity and, significantly, their vernacular qualities also playa vital role in creating the beauty of the cultural landscape. They have their own expression in architecture and landscape that could be identified as unique within the Malay Archipelago. The study will also consider the Kelantan traditional Malay house, the village, and the landscape elements of the capital city of Kota Bharu. This research will also look into the influences from other landscape traditions in creating the Kelantan Malay cultural landscape. These include the early stage of Kelantan, during the HinduBuddhist era, the philosophy and culture of the Islamic era, Siamese influence, British colonial influence, and the period after Independence in 1957. In addition, this research will look into the approaches that have been used by Kota Bharu Municipal Council in creating the new landscape, especially in the city centre. At the same time the process of creating the regional identity will be considered. Kota Bharu, as an Islamic city, represents a symbolic trademark to the urban development of the Islamic state of Kelantan. It appears that there have been many changes in the cultural landscape of Kelantan, especially in the traditional villages and the city centre, that have gradually been transformed. In an important sense, recent new building and new urban development have transformed the cultural landscape either in a traditional matter or in a pastiche way. This thesis recognises the importance of incorporating the existing heritage alongside contemporary design. This research also seeks to consider the future prospects for the Kelantan Malay cultural landscape since there are many evolutions currently underway. Optimistically, there will be better landscape practices in the future, as well as further research on the Kelantan Malay cultural landscape.


Ahmad,  KB.  (2002) An Overview of Architecture Education  in the Contemporary  Muslim World.  In: 

Petruccioli, A  & Pirani,  KK,   2002. Understanding  Islamic Architecture,  Oxon: RutledgeCurzon, 

pp. 129-132.


Akib,   M.S.,Yaacob,   A,Jusoh,W.J.And   Ibrahim,S .(2000)  Muzium-muzium   di   Kelantan. 

Malaysia. Perbadanan Muzium Negeri Kelantan.


Andaya,  L.Y.(2001)  The  Search  for  the  ' Origins '  of  Melayu.  Journal  of  Southeast  Asian 

Studiest, 32(3), 315-330


Antrop,  M.  (2004)    Rural-urban  Conflicts  and  Opportunities.    The  Dimensions  of  the 

European Landscape, 83-91


Antrop,  M.  (2005)  Why  landscapes  of  the  past  are  important  for  the  future.  Landscape 

Urban Planning. 70 (l-2), 21-34


Ardalan,  N.(2002)  "Simultaneous  Perplexi ty":  The  Paradise  Garden  as  the  Quintessential 

Visual  Paradigm  of Islamic  Architecture  and  Beyond .  In:  Petruccioli,  A  and  Pirani,  K K 

, 2002. Understanding Islamic Architecture , Oxon: RutledgeCurzon, pp. 9-18.


Ariffin, S.I., Order in traditional Malay house form, Ph.D. thesis, Oxford Brookes,(2001).


Assi,   E.  (2000)  Searching   for  the  concept  of  authenticity:   implementation  guidelines. 

Journal of Architectural Conservation,  6(2), 60-69


Atwah,  A.Y.A.,  Identification and  understanding  of the cultural  landscape of Arabia . Case 

study: 'Asir region in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, Ph.D. thesis, Edinb urgh,(1992).


Awang,   K,   Tourism   Development   in  Peripheral   Area  of  Malaysia:   a  Case  Study  of 

Kelantan, Ph.D. thesis, Wales, Aberystwyth,(2006).


Bogdan,  R.C., & Biklen, S.K  (2007) Qualitative  research for education:  An introduction to 

theories and methods. Boston: Pearson.


Bosselman,  P.C.,  Kondolf,G.M.,  Jiang,  F.,Geping,  B.,  Zhang,  Z.  and  Mingxin,  L.  (2010) 

The Future of a Chinese WaterVillage.  Alternative  Design Practices  Aimed to Provide New Life for 

Traditional Water Villages in the Pearl River Delta, Journal of Urban Design, 15(2) , 243-267


Breuste, J.H.(2004) Decision Making, Planning and Design for the Conservation of Indigenous 

Vegetation within Urban Development. Landscape Urban Planning 68 (4), 439- 452.


Bunnell, T. (2002) Kampung Rules:  Landscape and the Contested  Government  of Urban(e) Malayness.  

Urban Studies, 39(9), 1685 -  1701


Davies,  P.  & Robb,  J.  (2002) The  appropriate  of  the  material  of  places  in  the  

landscape, Landscape Research, 27(2), 181-185


deMarrais, K (2004) Qualitative interview studies: Learning through experience.  In K

deMarrais & S.D.Lapan (Eds.), Foundations for research. Mahwah, NJ: Ertlbaum


Dobby, E.H.G.(1942) Settlement Patterns in Malaya. Geographical  Review,32(2), 211-232.


Endut,  E.H.,  Traditional  Malaysia  built  forms:  a  study  of the origins,  main  building  

types, development  of building  forms, design  principles  and the application of traditional  

concepts in modem building, Ph.D. thesis, Sheffield,(1994).


Fee, C.V.(1998) The Encyclopaedia  of Malaysia:  Architecture.  Kuala Lumpur:  Archipelago Press.


Firth, R. (1943) The Coastal People ofKelantan and Trengganu, Malaya  The Geographical Journal, 

Vol. 101, No. 5/6, 193-205.


Frampton, K  (1983). Towards a critical regionalism: six points for an architecture of resistance, 

in H. Foster (Ed.) The Anti-Aesthetic (Port Townsend, Washington:  Bay Press)


Francis, M.(1999) A Case Study Method for Landscape Architecture.  Landscape Journal 20: 1-01, 


Gospodini,A.   (2004)   Urban   Morphology   and   Place   Identity   in  European   Cities:   

Built Heritage and Innovative Design.   Journal of Urban Design, 9(2), 225-248.


Graham, W.A.(1908) Kelantan A State of the Malay Peninsula:  A Handbook oflnformation. James 

Maclehose and Sons, Glasgow.


Haaren,  C.V.(2002)  Landscape  Planning  Facing   the  Challenge  of  the  Develo pment  of 

Cultural Landscapes.  Landscape and Urban Planning 60,73-80


Haider, S.G.(1984) Habitat and values in Islam: a conceptual formulation of an Islamic City. In: 

Sardar, Z., 1984. The touch of Midas Science, values and environment in Islam and the West, 

Manchester: Manchester University Press, pp. 170-208.



Hay,  R.  (1998)  A  rooted 245-266

sense  of  place  in  cross-cultural  perspective.  Can.  Geogr.





Hough,   M.(1990)   Out   of   Place:   Restoring   Identity   to  The  Regional   Landscape.   

Yale University  Press,New Haven & London.


Hubbard, P. (1994) Professional  vs Lay Tastes in Design Control-an empirical investigation. 

Planning Practice and Research,9(3), 271-287


International  Federation  of  Landscape  Architects  (IFLA)  (no  date)  Cultural  Landscapes. 

[Online]  content&view=article&id==29&Itemid=40

[Accessed 14?? January 2011)


Jiven,   G.   and   Larkham,   P.J.   (2003)     Sense  of   Place,   Authenticity   and  

Character:   A Commentary.   Journal of Urban Design, 8(1),67-81


Jones, M. (Ed.)(1990) Fake? The Art of Deception (London, British Museum Publication).


Kiernan, V.G.(1956) Britain, Siam, and Malaya: 1875-1885. The Journal of Modern History, Vol. 

28(1), pp. 1-20


King, AD.  (1976) Colonial Urban Development (London:  Routledge & Paul)


Land   Use   Consultants   (2009)   Guidelines   for   Implementing   the   European   Landscape 

Convention:  what does it  mean for your  organisation?  A Report to Natural England.  LUC: London. 



Langhof,  C.  and  Adler,  G.(1997)  Win-win  in  Urban  Design.  The  Journal  of  Architecture, 

2(3), 245 -  250


Larco,  N.  (2010)  Both/And:  Merging  Global  and  Local  Identity  through  Design.  A  Case 

Study of Puerto Madero, Buenos Aires. Journal of Urban Design, 15(2), 195-210


Larkham, P.J. (1996) Conservation and the City (London, Routledge).


Leighly,  J.  (1965)  Land  and Life:  A Selection  from  the Writings  of C.O.Sauer.  Berkeley. 

University of California Press, 343


Lim Jee Yuan. (1997) The Malay House. Pulau Pinang: Institut Masyarakat.


Lowenthal, D. (1990) Forging the past, in: M.Jones (Ed.) Fake? The Art of Deception,  16-22 

(London, British Museum Publications).


Lynch, K  (1960) The Image of the City. Cambridge, MA, MIT Press.


Mahgoub,  Y.  (2007)  Architecture  and  the Expression  of Cultural  Identity  in  Kuwait.  The 

Journal of Architecture 12(2), 165 -  182


Mahmud,  Z.  (2004)    Traditional  Landscapes  of  the  Malays  of  the  Peninsula.  Malaysia. 

Universit Pendidikan Sultan Idris.


McClelland,   L.F.(1991)     Imagery,   Ideals,   and   Social   Values:   The   Interpretation   

and Documentation  of Cultural Landscapes. The Public Historian, 13(2), 108


McCutcheon,  M.S.,  Change,  continuity  and  cultural  identity  as  traced  through  the  people 

and place of Arnbohimanga,  Madagascar,  D.Phil. thesis, Oxford,(2003).


McHarg, I. (1969) Design With Nature. New York. Doubleday/Natural History Press.


Merriam,  S.B.  (2009)  Qualitative  Research:  A  guide  to  design  and  Implementation.  San 

Francisco: Jossey-Bass A Wiley Imprint.


Michell,  G.  (1995)  Architecture  of  the  Islamic  World:  Its  History  and  Social  Meaning, 

London: Thames & Hudson.


Montgomery,  J.R.  (1998)  Making  a  city:  urbanity,  vitality  and  urban  design.  Journal  of 

Urban Design, 3(1), 93-ll6


Montgomery,  J.R.  (2003) Cultural Quarters as Mechanisms  for Urban Regeneration.  Part  I: 

Conceptualising Cultural Quarters, Planning, Practice & Research, 18(4),293-306


MPKB-BI.(2002) Kota Bharu Landscape Master Plan Report.


MPKB-BI.(2006a)  Kota  Bharu  Municipal  Council-  Islamic  City  2006-2015  Master  Plan Report.


MPKB-BI.(2006b) Kota  Bharu  Municipal  Council-  Islamic  City  Action  Plan  and  Design 

Guidelines Report.


Nasir,  A.H.  (1985)  Pengenalan  Rumah  Tradisional  Melayu  Semenanjung.  Kuala  Lumpur: Loyal 

Press Sdn. Bhd.


Nasir,  AH   and  Teh,  W.W.H.  (1997)  Warisan  Seni  Bina  Melayu.  1??  ed.  Bangi:  Penerbit 

Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia


Nasir,  A.H.  (1979)  Guide  to  Historical  Sites  Kelantan. l ??  ed.  Kuala  Lumpur:  Museum 



Neuman,  M.(2000)  Regional  Design  :  Recovering  a  Great  Landscape   Architecture  and Urban 

Planning Tradition. Landscape and Urban Planning 47,115-128


Nusser,  M.(2001)  Understanding  Cultural  Landscape  Transformation:  a  re-Photographic Survey 

in Chitral, Eastern Hindukush, Pakistan. Landscape and Urban Planning 57, 241-255


Omar,  I.A   (1979)  Konsep  Ruang  Rumah  Melayu.  In:  Yahya,  M.A.  (1995)  Simbolisme dalarn 

Seni Bina Rumah Melayu,  Kuala Lumpur: Dewan Bahasa dan Pustaka.


Ouf, A.M.S. (2001)  Authenticity and the Sense of Place in Urban Design.  Journal of Urban Design, 



Ozkan, S.  (2002) Modernity  and Tradition:  Problem and  Potential.  In:  Petruccioli,  A   And 


Pirani, KK   (2002) Understanding  Islamic Architecture, Oxon: RutledgeCurzon, pp. 85-97.


Pattacini,  L.  (2001)    Landscape  and  Design  Guidance:  Saint  Gervais-les-Bains,  a  Case­ 

study.  Journal of Urban Design, 6(3), 317-325


Pendlebury,   J.  (2005)  The  Modem  Historic  City:  Evolving  Ideas  in  Mid-20??  Century 

Britain. Journal of Urban Design, 10: 2, pp. 253-273


Petherbridge,  G.T.  (1995)  Vernacular  Architecture:  The  House  and  Society.  In:  Michell, 

G.(1995)  Architectural  of  the  Islamic  World:  Its  Histoty  and  Social  Meaning,  London: 

Thames & Hudson, pp. 176 -208


Rahman,  N.A.N.H.S  et.  al (1998)  Early  Histoty:  The  Encyclopaedia  of  Malaysia.  Kuala 

Lumpur. Archipelago  Press.


Rasdi,  M.T.M.,  Ali,KM.,  Ariffin,  S.A.I.S.,  Mohammad,  R   And  Mursib,  G.  (2005)  The 

Architectural  Heritage  of  the  Malay  World-The  Traditional  Houses.  Malaysia.  Universiti 

Teknologi Malaysia


Rayburn,  AP.   &  Schulte,  L.A.(2009)  Landscape  change  in  an  agricultural  watershed  in 

U.S.Midwest, Landscape and Urban Planning, 93(2), 132-141

Relph, E. (1976) Place and Placelessness (London, Pion).


Robert   KYin.   (1994)   Case   Study   Research:    Design   and   Methods.    London.   Sage 



Robertson, I. & Richards, P. (2003) Studying Cultural Landscapes, London: Arnold.


Ruggles,  D.F.  (2008)  Islamic Gardens  and  Landscapes.  1??  ed.  Philadelphia:  University  of 

Pennsylvania Press, pp.89.


Said,  I.  (2001)   Cultural-Ethnic Landscape  of Terrace  Housing  Community  in  Peninsular 

Malaysia.  Journal of Technology B, 35,1-27


Said, I. (2001)   Pluralism in Terrace Housing Community  through Ethnic Garden.   Journal 

ofTechnology  B, 35,41-53


Said,  I.  (2002)  Visual  Composition  of  Malay   Woodcarvings   in  Vernacular   Houses  of 

Peninsular  Malaysia.  Jurnal Teknologi,  [Online]  Dis.  2002, 37(B),  pp. 43-52.  Available at: [Accessed 11 March 2010].


Saleh,  M.  (1998)  The Integration  of Tradition  and  Modernity:  A Search  for  an  Urban and 

Architectural  Identity in Arriyadh,  the Capital  of Saudi Arabia. Habitat International, 22(4), 



Salleh,  M. A.(2003)  Masjid  Kampung  Laut.  1??  ed.  Malaysia.  Perbadanan  Muzium  Negeri 



Salleh, N.M(l 982) Warisan Kelantan I. Malaysia  Perbadanan Muzium Negeri Kelantan. 


Salleh, N.M(l984) Warisan Kelantan III. Malaysia.  Perbadanan Muzium Negeri Kelantan. 


Salleh, N.M(l985) Warisan Kelantan IV. Malaysia.  Perbadanan Muzium Negeri Kelantan. 


Salleh, N.M(l986) Warisan Kelantan V. Malaysia  Perbadanan Muzium Negeri Kelantan. 


Salleh, N.M(l990) Warisan Kelantan IX. Malaysia. Perbadanan Muzium Negeri Kelantan.


Salleh, N.M(l992) Warisan Kelantan XI. Malaysia.  Perbadanan Muzium Negeri Kelantan.


Sauer,  C.O.(1925) The Morphology  of Landscape.  University  of California  Publications  in 



Schein, R.H.(1999) Teaching "Race" and the Cultural Landscape. The Journal of Geography 98( 4), 



Schmidt,  S.  (2005)  Cultural  Influences  and  the  Built  Environment:   An  Examination  of 

Kumasi, Ghana, Journal of Urban Design, 10(3), 353-370


Scott,   O.R.(1979)   Utilizing   History  to  Establish  Cultural   and  Physical   Identity   m  

the Landscape. Landscape Planning 6,179-203


Selman, P.H. (2006) Planning at the Landscape Scale. Routledge, London.


Shadar, H. (2010) Evolution and Critical Regionalism  Journal of Urban Design. 15(2), 227- 242


Shamsuddin,  S.,  Identity  of place:  a study  of Kuantan town centre,  Malaysia,  Ph.D.  thesis, 



Shamsul, A. B. (1988)  Kampung:  Antara Kenyataan Dengan Nostalgia, Dewan Masyarakat, December, 



Sinha, A. and Sharma, Y. (2009) Urban Design as a Frame for Site Readings of Heritage Landscapes: A 

Case Study of Champaner- Pavagadh, Gujarat, India. Journal of Urban Design, 14(2), 203-221


Stephenson,  J.(2008) The Cultural Values  Model  : An  Integrated  Approaches  to Values  in 

Landscape. Landscape and Urban Planning 84,127-139


Stratford-on-Avon (2001) District Desig n Guide (Stratford  upon Avon, Stratford upon Avon District 



Tahir,   O.M.,   Urban   landscape   management   in   Malaysia:   in   search   of   a   

sustainable management system, Ph.D. thesis, Newcastle upon Tyne,(2005).


Taylor,   P.D.(2002)   Fragmentation   and   cultural   landscapes:   tightening   the   

relationship between human beings and the environment.  Landscape and Urban Planning 58,93-99


Tiesdell,  S.(2002) The New Urbanism  and English Residential  Design Guidance:  a review, Journal 

ofUrban Design, 7(3), 353-376


Tisher, W.H.(1979)  The Landscape:  An Emerging  Historic Preservation  Resource.  Bulletin of the 

Association for Preservation Technology, Vol. 11, 4, 9-25


Thomas, G. (2009) How to do Your Research Project: A guide for students in Education and applied 

social sciences.  1?? ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.


UNESCO  World  Heritage  Cultural  Landscape  Definitions  in  International  Federation  of 

Landscape           Architecs           (IFLA)           [Online]           2008.           

Available           at: [Accessed  23 June 20IO].


Vos,  W.  And  Meekes,  H.(1999)  Trends   in  European  Cultural  Landscape  Develo pment: 

Perspectives  for a Sustainable Future. Landscape and Urban Planning 46, 3-14


Wansborough,   M   &   Mageean,   A    (2000)      The   Role   of   Urban   Design   m   Cultural 

Regeneration.   Journal of Urban Design, 5(2),181-197


Watson, G. B. & Bentley, I., 2007. Identity by Design. 1?? ed. Oxford: Architectural Press.


Whitehand,   J.W.R.   &  Gu,   K(2006)   Research   on   Chinese   urban   form:retrospect   and 

prospect, Progress in Human Geography, 30(3), 337-355


Yin, R.K   (2008) Case study  research:  Design  and methods  (4?? ed.).  Thousand  Oaks,  CA: 



Yunus, AH.M.,Urban Conservation  in  Malaysia:  Processes and Management,  Ph.D. thesis,




















































































This material may be protected under Copyright Act which governs the making of photocopies or reproductions of copyrighted materials.
You may use the digitized material for private study, scholarship, or research.

Back to previous page

Installed and configured by Bahagian Automasi, Perpustakaan Tuanku Bainun, Universiti Pendidikan Sultan Idris
If you have enquiries with this repository, kindly contact us at or Whatsapp +60163630263 (Office hours only)