Abdul  Hak, Nora (2004) PEL promotes teamwork  among students:  an experience  in Ahmad  Ibrahim  

Kulliyyah  of Laws,  IIUM  In:  Workshop  on  Problem  Based Leaming,  December 2004, Ahmad  

Ibrahim  Kulliyyah  of Laws (Unpublished Article).

 

Abdullah,  S.,  Omar,  M.  Z.,  Sahari,  J.  & Abd  Wahab,  D. (2006):  The  infusion  of Lifelong  

 Leaming   Skills   through   PBL   in   Engineering   Design   Courses. Prosiding Seminar 

Pengajaran dan Pembelajaran Berkesan 2006, UKM.

 

Abimbola,  1.0.  (1998).  Teachers'  Perceptions  of  Important  and  Difficult  Content.

Journal of Functional Education 1 (1), 10-12.

 

Ahmad, H. A. & Siti, N. K. R. (2008) Problem-Based  Leaming in Physics Education: A  Study  on   

Engineering   Students.   Proceedings   of  Seminar   Kebangsaan Aplikasi Sains dan Matematik 2008 

(SKASM2008), Johar Malaysia.

 

Agran, M., Gilberts, G.H., Hughes, C., & Wehmeyer,  M. (2003). The effects of peer delivered   

self-monitoring  strategies   on   the  participation   of  students   with severe disabilities in 

general education classrooms.  Journal of Developmental and Physical Disabilities, 15, 79-91.

 

AIM  (2009).  The  blueprint  "Agenda  on  Innovative  Malaysian",  National  Taskforce on 

Innovative Human Capital (JKMIIN): MOHE, Malaysia.

 

Allen, D. E., Duch,  B.J., & Groh, S.E. (2001). Strategies for using groups.  In: Duch, B.J., Groh, 

S.E., Allen, D.E. (Eds.), The Power of Problem-Based  Learning: A Practical  'How  To'  for  

Teaching  Undergraduate  Courses  in Any  Discipline. Sterling, VA: Stylus Publications.

 

Auerbach, C. F. & Louise B. S. (2003). Qualitative  Data: An Introduction to Coding and Analysis.  

New York:  New York University Press.

 

Baharom, S. & Saad, M.I.M. (2009). Feedback and Reflection through the e-Leaming Platform:  A  

Window  into  Students'  Acquisition  of  Soft-Skills.  Malaysian Journal of Educational 

Technology, 9(2), 33-43.

 

Barrows,  H.S.  (1986).  A  taxonomy  of  problem-based   learning  methods.  Medical Education, 

20, 481-486.

 

Barrow,  H.  S. & Tamblyn,  R.N.  (1980).  Problem  based  learning:  An  approach  to medical 

education. New York: Springer.

 

Barrows, H. S. & Tamblyn, R. M. (1976). An evaluation of problem-based  learning in small groups  

utilizing a simulated  patient,  Journal of Medical  Education,  51, 52-54.

 

Belland,  B.  R.;  French,  B.  F.; &  Ertmer,  P. A. (2009) "Validity  and  Problem-Based Leaming  

 Research:   A   Review   of   Instruments   Used   to   Assess   Intended Leaming  Outcomes.  

Interdisciplinary  Journal  of  Problem-based   Learning, 3(1), 5.

 

Bickman,  L.,  &  Rog,  D.J.  (1998).  Handbook  of  applied  social  research  methods.

London: Sage Publications.

 

Boud,  D. J. &  Feletti,  G.  (1991).  The Challenge  of  Problem  Based  learning.  Kogan Page: 

London.

 

Boud,  D. J. (1985)  Problem-based  learning  in  perspective.  In: Boud,  D.J,.  Problem­ based  

learning  in  education  for  the  professions.  Sydney:  Higher  Education Research and 

Development Society of Australasia.

 

Bloom,  B.  S.  (1956)  Taxonomy  of  Educational   Objectives,   the  classification  of 

educational goals -  Handbook I: Cognitive Domain New York: McKay

 

Blumberg, B. (2000). "Evaluating the Evidence That Problem-Based  Learners are Self-Directed  

Learners: A Review of the Literature." In D. H. Evensen and C.

E. Hmelo (Eds.), Problem-Based  Learning: A Research Perspective on Learning Interactions. Mahwah, 

N.J.: Erlbaum,  199- 226.

 

Bybee,  J.  L.  (2002).  Cognitive  processes  in  grammaticalization.  In  Thomasello,  M. (Ed)  

The  New  Psychology  of  Language,  Volume  II.  New  Jersey:  Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Inc.

 

Cheaney, J. & Thomas S. I. (2005). "Problem-based Learning in an Online Course: A Case Study," 

International  Review of Research in Open and Distance Leaming. Retrieved  from 

http://www.irrodl.org/index.php/irrodl/article/view/267/433. Last accessed 12 January 2011.

 

Chin, C., & Chia, L. G. (2004). Problem-based  learning: Using students'  questions to drive 

knowledge construction. Science Education, 88(5), 707- 727.

 

Daniel D. C. (1992). Teaching critical thinking skills in the biology & environmental science 

classrooms. The American Biology Teacher, 54(8), 464-468.

 

DeHaan,   R.  L.   (2009).   Teaching   creativity   and   inventive   problem   solving   in 

science. CBE-Life Sciences Education, 8(3), 172-181.

 

Donham R. S., Schmieg F. I., & Allen D. E. (2001). The large and the small of it: A case study of  

introductory  biology  courses.  In: Duch  B. J., Groh  S. E.,  Allen

D.  E., editors. The Power of Problem-Based  Learning:  A Practical  'How  To' for Teaching Courses 

in Any Discipline. Stylus; Sterling, VA: 2001.

 

Escotet,  M.  A.  (1995).  "A  Teacher-Centered  University   Education:   Is  the  Core University 

Culture Different between Developed and Developing Countries?" Paper  Presented  at  Comparative  

and  International  Education  Society  Annual Meeting,         Boston,        Massachusetts,       

 Retrieved        on        28-12-2011, 

http://www.miguelescotet.com/docs/A%20TeacherCentered%20University%2 OEducation.pdf

 

Edwards, S. (2003). "The curriculum  is... '  Early childhood educators' conceptions of curriculum  

 and   developmentally  appropriate   practice:   a  comparative   case study across two Victorian  

early childhood educational  settings',  Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Monash  University, 

Australia.

 

Evensen, D. H., Salisbury-Glennon, J. D., & Glenn, J. (2001) "A Qualitative Study of Six  Medical  

Students  in  a  Problem-Based   Curriculum:  Toward  a  Situated Model  of  Self-Regulation." 

Journal  of  Educational  Psychology,  93(4),  659- 676.

 

Ertrner,  P.,  &  Newby,  T.  (1996).  The  expert  learner:  Strategic,  self-regulated  and 

reflective, Instructional Science, 24, 1-24.

 

Exploring   Bioethic,   National   Department   of   Health,   Department   of   Bioethics. 

Retrieved   from:   http://science.education.nih.gov/supplements/nih9/bioethics/ guide/teaching.htm 

(20/11/1 1).

 

Fauziah,   S.,   Hanafi,   A., Rozhan,   M.   I. &   Hisham,   D.   (2004).   Problem-Based 

Learning:  A  Study  of the  Web-Based  Synchronous  Collaboration. Malaysian Online Journal of 

Instructional Technology, 1(2), 1-2.

 

Gallagher,  S.A. (1997). Problem-based  learning:  Where did  it come from, what does it so,  and  

where  it  is going.  Journal  for  Education  of the  Gifted, 20(4),  332- 362.

 

Gallagher,  S.  A.,  Stepien,  W.  J.,  &  Rosenthal,  H.  (1992).  The  effects  of  problem­ 

based learning on problem  solving. Gifted Child Quarterly. 36(4), 195-200.

 

Gabr  Hala,  &  Mohamed   Nearmat.  (2010).  Effects  of  problem-based   learning  on 

undergraduate   nursing  students  enrolled   in   nursing  administration  course. International 

Journal of Academic research, 3(1), 154-164.

 

Gibbons,     P.    (2002) Scaffolding    Language    Scaffolding    Leaming, Heinemann, Portsmouth.

 

Hammond,  J.,  &  Gibbons,  P.  (2001).  What  is  scaffolding?  In  J.  Hammond  (Ed.), Scaffold: 

Teaching and learning in language  and literacy education. Sydney: Primary English Teaching 

Association, 24-31.

 

Hmelo-Silver,  C.  E.,  &  Lin,  X.  (2000).  The  development  of  self-directed   learning 

strategies  in  problem-based  learning.  In Evensen,  D., and  Hmelo, C.E. (Eds.), Problem-Based   

Learning:Research  Perspectives  on  Learning   Interactions, Erlbaum, Mahwah, NJ.

 

Hmelo-Silver,  C.E.  (2004).  "Problem-Based  Learning:  What  and  how  do  students learn?" 

Educational Psychology Review, 16(3), 235-266.

 

Hmelo-Silver,  C.  E.  &  Barrows,  H.  S.  (2008).  Facilitating  collaborative  knowledge 

building. Cognition and Instruction. 26(1), 48-94.

 

Hung, W., Bailey, J.H. & Jonassen,  D.H. (2003). Exploring the Tensions of Problem­ Based  

Learning:  Insights  from  Research.  In  Knowlton,  D.S.  &  Sharp,  D.C. (Eds.), Problem Based 

Learning in the Information Age. San Francisco: Jossey Bass.

 

Hung,  W.  (2009).  The  9-step  problem  design  process  for  problem-based  learning: 

Application  of the  3C3R  VB  Model,  Educational  Research  Review, 4,  118- 141.

 

Johnstone,   A.H.,  &  Mahmond,  N.A.  (1980).  Isolating  Topics  of  High   Perceived Difficult 

in School  Biology. Journal of Biology Education.  14 (2), 163-165.

 

Kass,  H.,  &  MacDonald,  A.  L.  (I 999).  The  learning  contribution  of  student  self­ 

directed building activity in science. Science Education, 83(4), 449 -  471.

 

Korthagen,  F.  A.  J  (2001).  Linking  practice  and  theory:  The  pedagogy  of  realistic 

teacher education. Mahwah, New Jersey: Lawrence Erlbaum  Associates.

 

Lai,  P.  &  Tang,  C.  (1999)  Constraints  affecting  the  implementation  of  a  problem­ based  

learning  (PBL)  Strategy  in  University  Courses.  Implementing  Problem Based  Learning  

Project:  Proceedings  of the  First  Asia  Pacific Coriference  on Problem  Based  Learning  (pp.  

193-200).   Hong  Kong:  The  University  Grants Committee   of   Hong   Kong,   Teaching   

Development   Project   on   Enhancing Health Science Education through Problem Based Learning.

 

Lising  L,  &  Elby  A  (2005).  The  impact  of epistemology  on  learning:  A  case  study from  

introductory  physics. American Journal  Physical and Physics Education, 73(4), 3,72-382.

 

Lin,   M.   &   Lucey,   T.   A.   (2010,   September-November).   Individual   and   Group 

Reflection   ' vategies:    What    We    Learned    from    Pre-service    Teachers. Multicultural 

Education, 18(1), 51-54.

 

Lynda and Megan. (2002), Authentic Problem-Based  Leaming: Rewriting Business Education, Pearson 

Education Asia Pte Ltd, Singapore.

 

Major,  C.  H.,  &  Palmer,  B.(200 I)  "Assessing  the  Effectiveness  of  Problem-Based Learning  

 in   Higher   Education:   Lessons   from   the   Literature."   Academic Exchange Quarterly, 

5(1), 4-  8.

 

Mala-Maung,  Azman   A. and Abas,  Z. W.   (2004).   Utilisation  of different  resources for 

self-directed  learning  by students  undergoing an integrated  problem-based medical  curriculum.  

Proceedings  at  International  Conference  on Assessment in Medical  Education:    Asian  and  

International  Perspectives.  University  of Hong Kong, October 2004

 

Markowitz,  D.,  DuPre,  M.,  Holt,  S.,  Chen,  S.,  Wischnowski,  M.  (2008)  "BEGIN Partnership: 

Using Problem-Based  Leaming to Teach Genetics and Bioethics." American Biology Teacher, 70(7), 

421-425.

 

Masek ,  Alias & Yamin,  Sulaiman. (2011). Problem  based  learning:  Adapting  model of    

monitoring    and    assessment    towards    changing    to    student    centred learning.  

Journal of Technical Education and Training, 2 (1), 9-19.

 

Miao, Y., Holst, S. J., Haake, J.M., & Steinmetz,  R. (2000). PBL  protocols: Guiding and    

controlling    problem    based    learning    processes    in    virtual    learning environments. 

  In   B.   Fishman   &   S.   O'Connor-Divelbiss   (Eds.),   Fourth International  Conference  of  

the  Learning  Sciences.  (pp.  232-237).  Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum.

 

Mierson, S. (1998). A problem-based  learning course in physiology for undergraduate and   graduate 

  basic   science   students. Advances   in   Physiology   Education 275(Supplement) Sl6- S27.

 

Ministry of Higher Education Malaysia. (2007). "Pelan Strategik Pendidikan Negara"

Retrieved  December 28, 2011, from

http://www.mohe.gov.my/webkpt_v2/transformasi.php?m=&lang=ENG

 

Nakhleh,   M.B.   (1992).   Why   some   students   don't   learn   Chemistry.   Journal   of 

Chemical Education, 69, 191-196.

 

Nieswiadomy,  R. (2008). Foundations of nursing research. (5th ed.) New Jersey, USA: Pearson 

Prentice Hall.

 

Norman,  G.  R. &  Schmidt,  H.G. (1992).  The  psychological  basis  of  problem-based learning: A 

review of the evidence. Academic Medicine, 67(9), 557-565.

 

Norman, G.  R., Brooks,  L. R., Colle, C., & Hatala,  H. (1998). Relative effectiveness of  

instruction   in  forward  and  backward   reasoning.   Paper  presented  at  the Annual   Meeting  

of  the  American   Educational   Research  Association,   San Diego, CA.

 

Okebukola,  P.A.O. (2005). Quality Assurances  in Teacher education in Nigeria; The roles  of  

faculties  of  education.  Paper  delivered  at  committees  of  Deans  of Education in Nigerian  

Universities.

 

Ozlem  Koray,  A.  P.,  Mustafa,  S.M.  &  Muhammet  0.  (2008).  Enhancing  problem­ solving  

skills  of  pre-service  elementary   school  teachers  through   problem­ based  learning.  

Asia-Pacific  Forum on Science  Learning  and Teaching, 9(2), 1-2.

 

Palincsar, A.S., Anderson, C.A., & David, Y.M. (1993). Pursuing scientific literacy in the middle 

grades through  collaborative  problem  solving.   Elementary School Journal, 93 (5), 643-658.

 

Pepper,   C.   (2009).   Problem   based   learning   m   science. Issues   In   Educational 

Research, 19(2), 128-141.

 

Rajendran  Nagappan.  (2000).  The Teaching  of  Higher  Order  Thinking  in  Malaysia.

Journal of Southeast Asian Education 2(1), 100-121.

 

Rose  Amnah,   A.  R.,  Abdul,   R.  J.,  Lilia,   H.  &  Siti,   R.  A.  (2004).   Pemupukan 

kemahiran  Proses Sains di  kalangan  pelajar tingkatan  dua di Sekolah  Bestari. Jurnal Teknologi, 

40(E), 19-32.

 

Sadiah Baharom., Ong, Eng Tek., Marzita Putih., Sopia Mat Yassin, NurulHuda Abd. Rahman   and   

Muhamad   Ikhwan   Mat   Saad,   (2009).   The   Validation   and adaptation  of  MLSQ  aimed  to  

assess  student  use  of  self-regulated  learning. Paper presented at 1st International 

Coriference  on Educational  Research and Practice  Enhancing  Human  Capital  through  Teacher  

Education  Faculty  of Educational  Studies UPM.

 

Salimah,  M.  &  Zaitun  A.B.  (2004).   PBL  Implementation:  an   Experience  of  the Faculty  of 

 Computer  Science  and   Information   Technology,   University   of Malaya. Malaysian Journal of 

Computer Science 2(1),  l-9.

 

Salomon,  G.,  Globerson,  T.,&  Guterman,  E.  (1989).  The  computer  as  a  zone  of proximal  

development:  Internalizing  reading-related  metacognitions  from  a Reading Partner. Journal of 

Educational  Psychology 81: 620-627.

 

Savery, J. R., & Duffey, T. M. (2001).  Problem  based  learning: An  instruction  model and    its 

  constructivist   framework.   CRLT   Technical   Report   No.   16-01. Bloomington,  IN:  Indiana 

 University  Center  for  Research  on  Learning  and Technology.

 

Savin-Baden,  M.  (2001).  The  problem-based   learning  landscape,  [Special  Edition]

Planet, 2, 4-6.

 

Savin-Baden,  M.  &  Major,  C.  H.  (2004).  Foundations  of  problem-based  learning.

England: Open University  Press McGraw Hill Education.

 

Schmidt,  H.G.  (1993).  Foundations  of  problem-based   learning:  Some  explanatory notes. 

Medical Education, 27, 422-432.

 

Schmidt,  H.  G.,  &  Moust,  J.  H.  C.  (2000).  Factors  affecting  small-group  tutorial 

learning:  A  review  of  research.  In  Evensen,  D.,  and  Hmelo,  C.  E.  (eds.), Problem-Based  

Learning:  A  Research  Perspective  on  Learning  Interactions, Erlbaum, Mahwah, NJ.

 

Schoenfeld-Tacher, R.,  McConnell,  S., &  Kogan,  L. (2004). "Taking  it online -  the effects of 

delivery medium and facilitator on student achievement  in problem­ based learninff'  American  

Educational  Research Association Annual  Meeting, San Diego, CA.

 

Shahrizan Baharom, Roszilah  Hamid and Noraini Hamzah (2011): Implementation of Problem  Based  

Learning  in Concrete  Laboratory  Work. Kongres  Pengajaran dan  Pembelajaran  (PeKA' 11).  

Unpublished  manuscript,  National  University of Malaysia, (UKM).

 

Susan Koba & Annae Tweed. (2009). 'Hard-to-teach biology concepts: a framework to  deepen  student  

 understanding';  National   Science   Teacher   Association Press.

 

Sopia Md Yasin, Ong E.T., Hashimah Alimon, Sadiah Baharom & Lai, Y. Y. (2010). Teaching     Science 

    Through     English:     Engaging     Pupils     Cognitively. International CLIL Research 

Journal,  I (3), 46-60.

 

Suzilawati    Shamsuddin.    (2007)."Kesan    Penggunaan    Pendekatan    Pembelajaran Berasaskan   

Masalah   Terhadap   Pencapaian,   Kemahiran   Proses  Sains  Dan Motivasi  Pelajar  Dalam  

Pengajaran  Dan  Pembelajaran  Biologi"  Unpublished m ster's thesis, Universiti Pendidikan Sultan 

Idris, Malaysia.

 

Tan Oon-Seng (2003). Problem-based  learning Innovation: Using problems to power learning in the 

21'1  century. Singapore: Thomson Leaming

 

Tan    Oon-Seng    (2004).    Enhancing    thinking   through    problem-based    learning 

approaches international perspectives. Singapore: Thomson  Leaming

 

Tsui,  C.-Y.,  &  Treagust,  D.  F.  (2003).  Genetics  reasoning  with  multiple  external 

representations. Research in Science Education, 33(1), 111-135.

 

Torp,  L and  Sage,  S. (2002).  Problems  as possibilities: Problem-based  learning  for K-16  

education.  2nd  Edition.  Alexandria:  Association  for  Supervision   and Curriculum  

Development.

 

Torp, L., & Sage,  S. (1998).  Problems  as Possibilities: Problem-based  learning  for K-12 

education.  Alexandria,  VA: Association  for Supervision  and Curriculum Development.

 

University    of    Delaware Problem-Based    Learning    Clearinghouse. Available    at

.https://www.mis4.udel.edu/Pbl/index.jsp. Accessed on 14th April 2011

 

Universiti  Teknologi  Malaysia.  2005.  Centre  for  Teaching  and  Learning  (CTL)  and Human 

Resource Development (HRD). http://www.ctl.utm.my (11 Nov 20 I 0).

 

University of Rochester Life Sciences Learning Center. Retrieved from the WWW on 2/20/11. 

http://lifesciences.envmed.rochester.edu.

 

Vogler, K. E. (2005). Improve Your Verbal  Questioning,  The Clearing House, 79(2). 98-103.   

Retrieved   October   23,   2011,   from   Academic   Research   Library. (Document  ID: 

977221771).

 

Vygotsky,  L. S. (1978). Mind in society. Cambridge,  MA: MIT Press.

 

Waters, R. & McCracken,  M. (1996). Problem-Based  Learning in Computer  Science, 5th  Annual  

Conference  on  Problem-Based  Learning.  Available  at  http://fie­ 

conference.org/fie97/papers/1454.pdf (accessed  28/12/11 ).

 

Williams, C., Stanisstreet,  M., Spall,  K.E.,  Boyes,  E. & Dickson,  D.P.E. (2003).Why aren't 

secondary students interested  in physics? Physics Education 38 (4), 324- 329.

 

Willis,  S.C.,  Jones,  A.,  Bundy,  C.,  Burdett,  K.,  Whithouse,  C.R.,  &  O'Neill,  P.A. 

(2002)  Small-group  work  and  assessment  in  a PBL  curriculum:  a  qualitative and quantitative 

evaluation  of student  perceptions of the process of working in small groups and its assessment. 

Med Teach, 24,495-501.

 

Winterton,   J.,   Delamare-Le   Deist,   F.   &   Stringfellow,   E.   (2006).   Typology   of 

knowledge,    skills   and   competences:   Clarification   of   the   concept    and prototype.   

Office   for   Official   Publication   of   the   European   Community, Luxembourg.         

Retrieved         on         December         9,         201 I,         from 

http://www.ecotec.com/europeaninventory/publications/method/CEDEFOP_ typology.pdf

 

West  African   Examinations   Council   (WAEC)   (1998).  Chief   Examiners'   Report, Lagos WAEC.

 

West African Examinations Council (WAEC) (2002). Chief Examiners  Report, Lagos (WAEC).

 

West African Examinations Council (WAEC) (2004). Chief Examiners  Report, Lagos (WAEC).

 

Wehmeyer,  M.  L.,  Agran,  M.,  &  Hughes,  C.  (2000).  A  national  survey  of  teachers' 

promotion   of  self-determination  and   student-directed  learning.   Journal  of Special 

Education, 34, 58-68.

 

Wu, Y. (2006). Applying a hybrid problem-based learning method to the teaching of computer 

programming. The China Papers.

 

Zainal Alam , Siti Nurzakiah (2007) Relationship between problem-based learning experience and 

self-directed learning readiness. Unpublished Master's thesis, Universiti Tun Hussein Onn, 

Malaysia.